Advertisement
*
Reproduction permitted for personal use only. For reprints and reprint permission, contact reprints@wistechnology.com.

Why the business community should take notice of WEAC's school reform plan

MADISON - It's easy to be cynical about the plan for school reform offered by the statewide teachers' union… almost too easy.

Yes, the proposal by the Wisconsin Education Association Council could have been floated at any time during the eight-year term of former Gov. Jim Doyle, a Democrat the union supported.

Yes, WEAC could have put forward its ideas for improving teacher quality, rewarding top teachers and fixing Milwaukee Public Schools last year before the federal government rejected Wisconsin's application for “Race to the Top” money.

And, yes, the leadership at WEAC certainly saw the handwriting on the chalkboard when Republican Gov. Scott Walker and a GOP-dominated Legislature swept the November elections.

Everyone knows all of that, however, so it doesn't take Prince Machiavelli to plot the obvious politics surrounding the WEAC plan. Simply put, the union is trying to stay ahead of the train.
Advertisement
But what really matters is that front-line educators have signaled they're ready for school reform - changes that could build a smarter, better-prepared workforce for Wisconsin. It's an offer that should not be shrugged off with an early dismissal bell.

For the first time, WEAC has endorsed reforms it previously opposed. Those include:

  • Dropping a teacher pay schedule that rewarded longevity and advanced degrees but little else. The union now supports “merit pay” based on performance, national certification, leadership roles, and how teachers handle more difficult assignments such as bilingual or special education, or teaching in under-performing schools.
  • Adopting student test results, a peer review panel, mentoring and other factors to root out ineffective teachers.
  • Breaking up the state's largest school district, Milwaukee Public Schools, into six smaller units within four years.

After WEAC's announcement last week, Walker praised the proposal and even telephoned the union's president, Mary Bell, to congratulate her. Then again, that olive branch was quickly followed by Walker's budget adjustment bill proposals to dramatically limit the power of public employee unions - including the teachers' union itself.

For now, let's assume a foundation for constructive conversation still exists. What should be the role of public education's ultimate consumers - businesses and the communities in which their employees live and work?

That role should be to support school reform, which is vital to Wisconsin's economic prosperity.

Study after study has revealed that American schools aren't producing enough students who can compete in the global economy. That's true even in Wisconsin, which prides itself on above-average performance in college placement scores, high-school graduation rates and more.

Trouble is, students in other nations are pulling ahead of their American counterparts by most measures - especially in science, technology, engineering and math, the so-called “STEM” disciplines. According to federal data, job openings requiring expertise in STEM fields will increase by 18.3 percent through 2014. Many of Wisconsin's fastest-growing industries and its highest-demand jobs are in fields that require rigorous training in science, technology, engineering and math.

Unless Wisconsin can produce more high-school graduates who are proficient in those disciplines and more, state businesses won't be able to fill critical jobs. Businesses that cannot find the workers they need close to home are often forced to expand elsewhere - hardly a formula for success. Poorly educated students rarely become the entrepreneurs of tomorrow.

That is particularly true in the Milwaukee area, where the state's largest school district is failing to educate many children. The largest city in Wisconsin cannot prosper without good schools, which are necessary over the long haul if Milwaukee hopes to renew its economy and its civic life.

It's easy to be cynical about WEAC's new-found religion, but it's also important to understand how the union works. Its leaders have been open to change for years, but have typically encountered stiff, behind-the-scenes opposition from old-school local bargaining units. On the other hand, about one-third of all WEAC members identify themselves as Republicans - a demographic that could back reform unless they feel backed into a corner.

The debate has begun over how to improve Wisconsin's public schools. Late or otherwise, it's a debate worth having.

Recent articles by Tom Still

Still is president of the Wisconsin Technology Council. He is the former associate editor of the Wisconsin State Journal.

The opinions expressed herein or statements made in the above column are solely those of the author, and do not necessarily reflect the views of Wisconsin Technology Network, LLC. WTN accepts no legal liability or responsibility for any claims made or opinions expressed herein.

Comments

Madison Parent, Wisconsin Taxpayer responded 2 years ago: #1

You state: "Its leaders [WEAC] have been open to change for years, but have typically encountered stiff, behind-the-scenes opposition from old-school local bargaining units."
I read: WEAC encountered entrenched, powerful resistance from one of Wisconsin's largest teacher unions - Madison Teachers' Union (MTI) who continue to be obstructionist to real educational reform.

I agree that educational reform measures AND reformed union operations both need to be understood and addressed in order to attain a meaningful level of overall reform success. I appreciate your expanding the scope of the recent conflict to the larger issue of education reform. How to accomplish educational reform is really at the heart of this week's conflict at the Capitol.

Is Walker’s execution plan overly aggressive and abrupt in initiating needed reform measures? I think yes. He should have waited to add this into the regular budget planning cycle and not pushed this into the current special legislative session under way. Right plan, poor tactics as I see things.
But until we can remove the partisan political pettiness in the change process no matter the timing of reform introductions, NOTHING good can result. In recent years, we have seen no progress under the existing negotiation structure and and process. And yes, Walker was elected democratically and tasked by the majority voters to legislate change. So I can't fault the him for taking action. Taxpayers, public and private worker leadership, legislators, union reps, and school administrators all need to regain civility, common sense, and fair communications as he among others attempts to get this done.

In regards to fair communications, in my opinion, Governor Walker is NOT eliminating collective bargaining as the media and union member leadership keep iterating in recent sound bites. He IS proposing that the scope of its use in contract negotiations be reduced. Wages can still be negotiated with collective bargaining as I understand his proposal. That seems like a fair adjustment to me as a taxpayer.

As a parent, it worries me that teachers and their leadership can smear Walker's intent and mislead the public in their lack of knowing the difference between the meaning of "eliminate" and 'reduce" and get away with that publicly. To have the local and national media re-iterate union sentiments using those inaccurate terms without correction - shame on them.

The students we are all purporting to educate as well as we can as a community of adults can see this communication contortion. Is there any wonder that among the best and the brightest of our youth, so many feel so disenfranchised with our teachers, mass media, and civic leadership? One quick fix to addressing the issue of poor classroom decorum and student motivation to learn is to expect and demand out teachers demonstrate intelligence as professionals while working both in and out of the classrooms. At this point, I am not convinced they have been doing so - especially this week. As the saying goes, the children are always watching us. For those children who are thinking critically and at high level on educational issues, none of us adults are getting high marks from them.
So let's all get it together for our kids for real. And quit being petty, self-centered, and narrow minded and not dealing with the larger educational problems at hand.

I always teach my kids that the true benchmark of adult maturity is whether or not one is able to solve life's problems that impact him or her and those around oneself effectively. I'd say collectively as adults when dealing with educational reform, we are all acting more like children at the moment. So let's all grow up, behave more civilly, communicate the facts more clearly, and get this needed reform accomplished.

Either that, or let our current students solve this for themselves and we can fully get out of the way if we can't behave like true adults after all.

And PS to Madison teachers - I'd feel perhaps a bit differently if you didn't have my kids watch full feature Hollywodd movies almost every week that have nothing to do with your class curriculum and waste their time and my tax dollars. You only have a handful of months each year as it is with my kids (your agrarian-based calendar year has got to go!) So teach already, will you please? And then let's talk more about your contracts...

-Add Your Comment

Name:
E-mail:

Comment Policy: WTN News accepts comments that are on-topic and do not contain advertisements, profanity or personal attacks. Comments represent the views of the individuals who post them and do not necessarily represent the views of WTN Media or our partners, advertisers, or sources. Comments are moderated and are not immediately posted. Your email address will not be posted.

WTN Media cannot accept liability for the content of comments posted here or verify their accuracy. If you believe this comment section is being abused, contact edit@wistechnology.com.

WTN InGroup
Advertisement
Madison High Tech Directory
WTN Media Presents